for your special day

Cakes

Wedding

30 years of Experience

Scroll Down

Cost

We are happy to work with any budget and can create cakes as simple or as elaborate as you like. Our cakes start at $3.25/serving. Quotes can be made for the flavors of your choosing. Free samples are provided. 

Customization

We understand that everyone has their idea of the perfect wedding cake. That is why our cakes are tailored to fit your individual needs.
 
We offer a free consultation so that you can discuss your ideas with us and work through the design of your cake. 

Quality

Our cakes are baked from scratch, baked at the last minute before decorating, using the freshest of ingredients. We provide complimentary samples of the flavor combinations of your choice prior to booking so you know exactly what you're getting. 

Choose Your Cake

Traditional Cakes

These classic flavors use our tried-and-true recipes that give you a light & moist texture with a rich flavor of choclate and vanilla. 
Chocolate           
Yellow
per serving
$3.25

Cheesecake

With a recipe that has been passed down through Sandra's family, this thick New York style cheesecake has a dense, but smooth & creamy consistency that will melt in your mouth. Baked in a graham cracker crust.
 
Add a fruit topping at an additional charge.  
per serving
$4.00

Specialty Cakes

These popular flavors will keep your guests coming back for more! Don't see your favorite flavor? Ask, as we can whip up just about anything!
Double Fudge
with fudge icing
Our classic chocolate cake layered with our homemade, thick & creamy fudge icing. 
per serving
$4.00
per serving
$4.25
German Chocolate
with fudge icing
Our double fudge cake with an added layer of our secret mixture of fresh coconut and pecans. 
Red Velvet
with cream cheese icing
Our classic red velvet cake has heavy hints of chocolate.  A moist and rich cake that adds beautiful color to your traditional chocolate cake. 
per serving
$4.00
Classic Carrot
with cream cheese icing
Our most popular cake for over 20 years, this cake has been handed down in the family for decades. This cake is balanced between dense and fluffy, providing a perfect bite of carrot and spices. Best served with our creamy cream cheese. 
per serving
$4.25

Choose Your Filling

Bavarian

A creamy, sweet filling that is thicker than a pudding, but lightened with whipped cream. 
Keep in mind this filling can not withstand long hours in warm temperatures. 
Chocolate           
Yellow
Chocolate           
Yellow
per serving
$3.25

Fresh Fruit

& Bavarian

Using our fresh cream, we layer fresh cut fruit on top. Fruit selection based on season. Same as above - this choice can not withstand long hours in warm temperatures. 
Strawberries
Blueberries
Blackberries
Peaches
per serving
$3.25

Buttercream

w/ fruit jam

A layer of fresh fruit jam on top of a thin homemade creamy buttercream layer. 
Strawberry
Raspberry
Lemon
per serving
$3.50

Choose Your Icing

Traditional Whipped Cream

Your lightest choice when it comes to a frosting. Whipped to the perfect consistency, this airy, semi-sweet frosting is perfect for those that do not want a sweet rich topping. 
Vanilla 
 
Chocolate
(extra cost)

Traditional Sweet Buttercream

A favorite of many, this buttercream is perfect for outdoor venues because it does not need to be refrigerated. This is a sweeter and heavier option to our whipped cream. 
Vanilla 
 
Chocolate
(extra cost)

Chocolate Fudge

Homemade, thick & creamy semi-sweet chocolate fudge. If you're a fan of Mackinac Island Fudge, then you'll love this! Keep in mind this rich frosting can not withstand long hours in warm temperatures - it will start to melt! 

Cream Cheese

If you're a cream cheese lover, this is the frosting for you! Our homemade recipe is thick and creamy, made with only the finest ingredients. We slowly stir in our mixer for hours, giving it the perfect balance of fluff without being too heavy while still providing elegant richness.

Rolled Fondant

Unlike many dry, clay-like fondants, ours is a soft and sweet dough that is rolled out smoothly to coat your cake. If you're looking for a uniform, sleek looking cake this is a great choice! 

©2018 Sandra Kay's Bakery. Website created by Northern Creative Dezign